Let’s get one thing straight: if you’re visiting Colorado Springs, you have to spend a day in Old Colorado City. This isn’t just another tourist stop; it’s the original capital of the Colorado Territory and the real historic heart of the Pikes Peak region. It’s where historic brick buildings house quirky art galleries, incredible restaurants, and one-of-a-kind shops.
But with so much to see, it’s easy to get overwhelmed. Don’t worry, I’ve got you covered. Here’s how to do Old Colorado City like you’ve lived here for years.
Table of Contents
- Start Your Day with the Perfect Coffee
- The Unmissable Old Colorado City Food Scene
- Immerse Yourself in Art and Culture
- Shop Like a Local (No Souvenir Magnets Here)
- Grab a Drink to End the Day
- Frequently Asked Questions
Start Your Day with the Perfect Coffee
Before you do anything else, you need caffeine. Skip the big chains and head straight to Jives Coffee Lounge. It’s got that perfect, cozy, lived-in feel with local art on the walls. The real secret here is to grab a seat by the window if you can—it’s the best spot for people-watching as the district wakes up. I always go for a simple, perfectly made latte.
If you’re in a hurry, Carnelian Coffee Co. is another fantastic choice with a slightly more modern vibe and seriously good espresso.
The Unmissable Old Colorado City Food Scene
This is where Old Colorado City really shines. You can find just about anything here, from quick bites to fine dining.
For a Casual, Unforgettable Lunch
You’re going to hear a lot of people talk about Monse’s Pupuseria, and for good reason. It’s an absolute institution. This is authentic, life-changing Salvadoran food.
- My Pro Tip: Don’t overthink it. Get the Pupusas Revueltas (pork, cheese, and beans) and a side of plantains. You have to order the horchata to drink—it’s creamy, cinnamon-y perfection. It gets busy, so try to go for a slightly early or late lunch to avoid the main rush.
Another fantastic option is Bon Ton’s Cafe. It’s been around forever and serves up classic Creole and American diner food. It’s simple, delicious, and feels like stepping back in time.
For a Memorable Dinner
When the sun goes down, the patios light up. For a fantastic date night or special occasion, you have two can’t-miss options.
- Paravicini’s Italian Bistro: This is loud, lively, East Coast-style Italian food. It’s not a quiet, romantic spot; it’s a place where you eat amazing pasta, drink good red wine, and feel like part of the family. You absolutely need a reservation, especially on weekends. The Veal Saltimbocca is legendary.
- Pizzeria Rustica: If you’re craving authentic, wood-fired Neapolitan pizza, this is the place. Tucked away in a charming historic house with a stunning back patio, it’s an experience. The crust is chewy, the toppings are fresh, and the ambiance is perfect on a summer evening.
Immerse Yourself in Art and Culture
Old Colorado City is a designated Creative District, and it’s packed with galleries showcasing local and national artists. You could spend a whole day just wandering from one to the next.
The Must-See Galleries
- Hunter-Wolff Gallery: This gallery feels very high-end but the staff is incredibly welcoming. They have a fantastic collection of paintings and bronze sculptures, focusing on Western and wildlife themes.
- 45 Degree Gallery: This is my personal favorite for more contemporary and colorful art. They have a wonderful, eclectic mix of ceramics, glasswork, and paintings that feel fresh and modern. It’s the perfect place to find a unique piece to take home.
A Truly Bizarre and Wonderful Experience
You cannot leave Old Colorado City without visiting the Michael Garman Museum & Gallery. From the street, it looks like a normal gallery. Inside, it’s a different world. Garman is famous for his sculptures of American archetypes, but the real draw is “Magic Town.” It’s a massive 1/6-scale miniature city in the back of the gallery, complete with holographic ghosts and gritty, detailed urban scenes. It’s weird, it’s fascinating, and kids and adults both love it.
Shop Like a Local (No Souvenir Magnets Here)
The shops here are as unique as the galleries. Walk down Colorado Avenue and pop into whatever catches your eye.
- Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory: Yes, it’s a chain, but it’s a Colorado classic. The smell alone is worth the visit. Grab a caramel apple or a few pieces of fudge.
- The Olive Tap: A must-visit for foodies. You can sample dozens of gourmet olive oils and balsamic vinegars. The Tuscan Herb Olive Oil is a staple in my kitchen.
- Jen’s Pottery Den: If you’re looking for a hands-on activity, this is it. Spend an hour or two painting your own pottery. It’s a great way to create a personal souvenir.
Grab a Drink to End the Day
After a full day of walking, you’ve earned a drink.
- Mother Muff’s: This is a true Old Colorado City dive bar. It’s been here forever, it’s no-frills, and it’s full of character (and characters). Go for the cheap beer and the authentic local vibe.
- Tap Traders: For the craft beer lover. They have a huge self-pour tap wall, so you can buy a card and sample as many different beers, ciders, or wines as you want. It’s a fun, interactive way to find a new favorite.
Old Colorado City has a magic that’s hard to describe. It’s a place to slow down, wander, and discover something new around every corner. Enjoy it!
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Old Colorado City worth visiting?
Absolutely. Old Colorado City is one of the most charming and historic neighborhoods in Colorado Springs. It offers a unique blend of award-winning restaurants, art galleries, and boutique shopping that you can’t find anywhere else in the city. It’s a perfect destination for a leisurely afternoon or a full day of exploration.
What is Old Colorado City known for?
Old Colorado City is best known for being the original capital of the Colorado Territory in 1861. Today, it’s famous for its preserved Victorian architecture, its status as an official Creative Arts District, and its vibrant main street (Colorado Avenue) filled with local shops, galleries, and some of the best restaurants in the Pikes Peak region.
How much time do you need in Old Colorado City?
You can get a good feel for Old Colorado City in about 3-4 hours, which is enough time to browse the shops, visit a gallery or two, and have a meal. To fully experience everything without rushing, including multiple galleries, a leisurely dinner, and perhaps a drink, a full day is highly recommended.
Is parking difficult in Old Colorado City?
Parking can be tight, especially on weekends. While there is free street parking along Colorado Avenue and the side streets, the spots fill up quickly. The best local tip is to look for the free public parking lots located just off the main avenue, such as the one behind the Simpich Showcase and another behind the Old Colorado City History Center.
After a day of exploring the historic streets and shops, you’ll want a comfortable and stylish place to come back to. Our Springline Stays homes are just a short drive away, providing the perfect modern retreat to relax and recharge for your next Colorado Springs adventure.
Book your perfect Colorado Springs getaway with Springline Stays!